Popagandhi

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Contact
  • Departments
    • dispatch
    • food and music
    • general
    • glbt
    • site
    • soundbites
    • tech
    • travel
  • Subscribe via RSS

Dreaming of India

October 3rd, 2005  |  Published in travel  |  24 Comments

My clandestine affair with India began, if I remember quite precisely, in a lift. I was six. A strikingly handsome man of Indian descent stepped in, with his similarly striking wife. My mother and I couldn’t help but stare. After he stepped out at the sixth floor, my mother said to me: “Girl, if you marry an Indian man, you can give me very good-looking grandchildren.”

I still don’t have the heart to tell her I wasn’t looking at the man. I was thinking, in fact, of India, and how the word rolled off my tongue with such mystery and aplomb.

Cut to present day, modern Singapore, a pappadum addiction and many eyebrow threadings later. I’m sitting in a morning class listening to my lecturer drone on about resumes and other ridiculous stuff tailored for the future accountant/ banker this school is so good at producing. I’m suddenly seized with the brilliant idea… I HAVE to be in India this December. I have to, I want to, I’d love to; I’m going to be thinking about it until I do, and even then I wouldn’t be able to get enough of it.

I get asked a lot: Why India? Why not? Why? Because I love India. Why do you love India? Because I do, and why don’t you? But where do I begin?

I’ve constantly said that falling in love with India is a little like falling in love with the ugliest girl in class. You want to scream your love from the mountains but you can’t — people might laugh at you. You never thought you’d fall for her, it was such a remote possibility in the first place. But you did, and now you can’t expect anyone to understand, unless they’ve fallen for someone like her before.

To say India is an assault on the senses is putting it very lightly. To be sure, if you wanted to, you could visit her and insulate yourself perfectly from her — hire a driver, never walk on the streets, stay in the Oberoi, never break into a sweat despite the heat. But what’s the fun in that? It would be comfortable, insulated, clean, everything India isn’t. It takes a kind of madness to love cities where the PSI is constantly 300-400, there’s a dalit shooting himself up with heroin under the bridge, traffic is chaos and but then so is everything else.

But you can’t explain away an emotional attachment. Or maybe I suffer from some distant variant of Stockholm Syndrome.

I like sticking out like a sore thumb. It allows me to heighten the sense of consciousness, to be aware, to be conscious and aware of the fact you’re here and deal with it. And I can’t stick out more sorely than in India. In Phnom Penh the barangs stick out more than I do, and I masquerade perfectly as a local of Chinese descent; that my first words in Phnom Penh were in Teochew, only made me feel even more like… I’m not really that far from home. In Thailand I skip effortlessly to the local queue for the boats (missing the 10x more expensive foreigner tickets), navigate back alleys to find my way from one soi into the other by bumboat, fifteen baht a ride. Nobody looks until I start to speak. Anywhere else — Sydney, Brisbane, New York, London — nobody really cares, in these cities. There’re too many of my kind in these places anyway. Eat at a local deli near a university and someone struts in wearing a Raffles Junior College shirt complete with FBT shorts. India, is a different matter. I don’t know if I’m sticking out because of my skin colour, my gender, my dressing, my funny language, or all of the above. But people stare, and you learn to meet that stare.

Born and raised in Singapore, I strangely never got used to order. But here everything makes sense. It makes sense that to wait for a bus you join the largest congregation of people by the side of the road (provided they are not washing, bathing, peeing). It makes sense that to figure out what bus to take, whether or not you speak the language, you stand there listening to the two bus boys (one at the front door the other at the rear) shouting out the list of destinations in a tongue too quick for you to catch. Should you have hesitated for a second you still have the chance to sprint after it and grab the window grilles or the side of the bus.

If Bangkok traffic is chaos; Phnom Penh traffic is chaos without rule of law. But I still feel safe crossing a road in India by throwing myself headlong into the maddening traffic. knowing the taxi stops for me as I pass, because I’m there, and because the taxi stops the truck has to stop, and because the truck stops the cart behind him stops, too. I don’t know if I feel safe crossing a road in Singapore when the red man suddenly comes on as I’m in the midst of it; I know it doesn’t matter to the motorist that I’m there, it only matters that he’s right, especially if he’s a taxi driver (or a university student). Traffic in India, being part of it, and living to tell the tale, reinforces your belief in divine forces. To romanticize chaos and traffic, the sort of interaction, compromise, understanding and communication taking place every moment in the midst of traffic in any Indian city is incomprehensible but endlessly fascinating. It’s not like here where you sit in an air-conditioned car and wait for the traffic lights, or wait out a traffic jam. To move at all, you understand, is a miracle, to move without ever hitting anything even more of one. And in order to move, the driver of your vehicle, whether car or taxi or bus or auto-rickshaw, needs to constantly negotiate with those to his sides, rear and still keep his eyes on the front.

So I write, occasionally. It follows then that one of my favourite pastimes is to watch. There’s plenty to watch in India, you don’t get to stop watching. At every moment there is something happening, at every happening there is something else going on. I like how people congregate in front of a TV in the display of a shop when a cricket match comes on. How they follow the boombox a man is carrying, broadcasting a cricket match, and stick closely to him in order to listen. I like how it takes four people to make a chicken roll, one to flatten the dough, one to add the fillings, and another to put it in a bag, and the last to collect 15 rupees (S$0.50) from you. I like how there is someone manning every single phone booth in this country, how there is a man holding a weighing machine out of nowhere in the street, and if you were suddenly seized with the idea you want to weigh yourself, you can, for one rupee. I like how people actually understand my Bengali, or pretend to, then switch to perfect English right after. I like how when they write India versus Pakistan on the walls, I’m never sure if they mean cricket, or political tension.

Every second in India there is at least one person getting a haircut or a beard shaved, in public.

I like to think I have a wonderful sense of direction and navigation, I don’t usually get lost, and that takes out all the fun of travelling for me. I inherited my mother’s ability to just “get” a place even if I’ve only been there an hour. But you could spend forty years in India and never really “get” it, and I think the people I’ve met who live there have never really tried to, knowing they can’t. If we can’t even make sense of their trains, it would be presumptuous to try to “get” anything else. Every morning on the bus out of Narendrapur into central Kolkata, I saw the same sights but always saw something new every morning. I could walk around Gariahat or Park Street a dozen times and still feel like I’d never been there before. I don’t like the word tourist, much. Touring a place is not engaged travel. Travelling could be, though not necessarily. But there isn’t really a word that explains the kind of travel in which you try to be one with a place, is there? If there was, India might be the first to which you could apply this new term.

The first time I was there, I couldn’t stop thinking: I am really happy in this place, happy in a manner I’ve never known before, in a way I can’t make sense of. Nothing else really matters as long as I’m alive. And even if I were to drop dead in the midst of Sudder Street I might draw a crowd only because of my foreign skin, then the dogs might come lap me up, the dust settles and nothing about India, nothing about Sudder Street, changes one bit.

At a prata store in Tanjong Pagar, I asked a man if they had any masala tea.
This is always a cue for everyone I ask this to ask in return, if I’ve been to India before.
I always say I have, then volunteer the information that I too, think India is great.
He said, “See you back home in Kerala this December!”

This is the kind of self-fulfilling prophecy that I really want to see come true, and perhaps it just might.

The Town Pump
A Pump, Tollygunge, Calcutta

Responses

Feed
  1. suji says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 12:49 pm (#)

    can i go india with you too during the hols?

  2. Rupz says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 1:40 pm (#)

    Did you mean papadam?

  3. popagandhi says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 1:45 pm (#)

    Rupz: same lah.

  4. tinkertailor says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 2:27 pm (#)

    damn. now i wanna go also. your fault.

  5. pleinelune says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 2:37 pm (#)

    I am going this holidays! Yay! New Delhi, here i come. :)

    Where exactly have you been in India, besides Calcutta?

  6. jkaiser says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 3:08 pm (#)

    totally agree with u about india..been to bangalore and its offskirts thrice..n basically the whole place is an assault on ur senses..so much to see, feel, listen, smell n taste.. planning on going to the north in may.. ;)

  7. Dawn says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 5:16 pm (#)

    Shooshoo everyone please go to India so maybe air ticket prices to elsewhere will be forced down. And Adri since when have you been afraid of being laughed at when spouting your obsession with India?

  8. HellsBel says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 5:53 pm (#)

    since you’re the traveller here…. more so than me…. anything on Prague??? (and i can’t believe tt you’re still awake! – wrf to your ‘caption post’

  9. popagandhi says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 6:05 pm (#)

    Bel: I can’t believe you’re still awake reading blogs!

    I have midterms as my excuse, what’s yours?

    Prague — nope, nothing on that. Not yet. When you going?

  10. Jol says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 9:29 pm (#)

    I understand completely what it’s like to love someplace in a way that you can’t make fully communicable to other people unless they’ve experienced something like it, and I think this post captured some of my own knowledge of that emotion, even if my objet d’affection – the pastoral, small-town beauty of Britain – is very different from yours.

  11. dubby says:

    October 3rd, 2005 at 10:39 pm (#)

    HellsBel – When are you intending to go to Prague? I might be headed there.. next late spring/early summer. Okay I know its quite far away, but still. Just comparing notes. :)

  12. en says:

    October 4th, 2005 at 2:05 am (#)

    waves hands frantically Mid-terms! Projects! Assignments!

    oh wait. catches herself reading blogs um.

    scurries away

  13. wl says:

    October 4th, 2005 at 6:16 am (#)

    My sentiments exactly, but I guess on a lesser scale as compared to you. Whatever bursts of emotions I’d failed to articulate properly in words, you did so succinctly. Nice one on india.

  14. indian worker says:

    October 4th, 2005 at 7:09 am (#)

    liked what you wrote.

    even in india, i meet sch*lars fr our island who live in bubbles (drivers, restaurant food, private clubs) and freaked out when i told

    them some of the things like you did.

    And they will always go “oh, no you will get raped…oh no, you will get robbed…you will get food poisoning” I feel like telling them, you might as well not live life. Go home. (Insert bad language here)

    Many Toured India… not engaged. well written.

  15. vishra says:

    October 4th, 2005 at 4:09 pm (#)

    what i love the most about india, besides the food, is the fact that traffic there works on telepathy. used to close my eyes when sitting in an auto, because every second felt like an accident of the verge of happening. in fact that’s how all my 1st days in india are. after that, you get used to it, and learn to cross the road with eyes closed and to glare and use some choice words on the unfortunate motorist who looks a tad too impatient.

  16. Ashwin Kumar says:

    October 5th, 2005 at 1:38 am (#)

    yo. a post on this !! liked it.

    I never noticed this on my RSS reader. NetNewsWire is eating up your entries. :)

    the airfares maybe slightly expensive in Dec, since it is the holiday season. You can try Indian Airlines or one of the newer ones Jet Airways/Sahara. I hear JetStar Asia is starting flights too.

    Do update me on your travel details. I might be in the vicinity duringthe same time, maybe we can meet up there. :P

  17. HellsBel says:

    October 5th, 2005 at 3:39 am (#)

    Adri: heh… occassional insonmia and night is the best time for some drama mama, mellowdrama writings!

    Dubby: I need to hop on and ‘leaving on a jet plane’ soon… Prague is one of the whimsical choices. Perhaps I need to up and go and I thought it to be a beautiful city! If I go, it’d be before the end of the year.

  18. Ranj says:

    October 5th, 2005 at 7:28 am (#)

    Beautiful post. Feels a bit odd to be feeling the same things you do, though I AM from India… Not sure about all of India, but I am thoroughly fascinated by Kolkata. I love that place in a way that I cant explain to anyone. The reactions I get are worse and they make me wanna strangle those pple!! Haha Words like “Yeaw, yuck, how can you?” … it’s completely magical to say the least. Kolkata and your words!

  19. popagandhi says:

    October 5th, 2005 at 7:33 am (#)

    Ranj, I know exactly what you mean.. i’ve met people from other parts of india who are like… “I HATE calcutta, it’s full of bengalis.” Hehehe.

  20. J says:

    October 6th, 2005 at 4:52 am (#)

    Its nice to know that foriegners are fascinated by our country as well…The ugliest girl in class analogy is true I guess:)

    Amazing Blog…:)

  21. mel says:

    October 6th, 2005 at 5:13 am (#)

    have u read this book called shantaram by gregory david roberts. it converted me from ambivalent-about-ahnehplace to i-want-to-learn-marathi. now that is one dude who really loves india.

  22. Varunacharya says:

    October 6th, 2005 at 8:04 am (#)

    haha…. u sound like ur really into it la….not bad not bad… if u want i can tell u places to eat and shop…

    in some cities….

  23. kaini says:

    October 6th, 2005 at 4:10 pm (#)

    All that, and that, and that too, and then the way the taxi driver never knows where you want to go but will just lean out of the window and yell “UNCLEJI!” and ask someone, and the way no one has an address, and the way the street children will fucking break your heart with their sunken, beautiful eyes alone, and how everything is colours, colours and shadow, and how they hang little baby shoes on the car boot for luck, and all the kids love to dance, and the women wear their hair long and oiled, and in the highlands the cheekbones are as chiselled as the landscape, and oh fuck i want to go back to india too.

    all my love

    kaini

  24. vaishnavi says:

    October 7th, 2005 at 12:31 pm (#)

    hi,

    i can totally relate! i’ve been to mumbai at least 10 times so far, but every time i step out there’s something fantastically new masquerading as though it’s been there all along.

    loved your entry, it brought back a flood of fuzzy memories (:

Photostream

More void deck signsGrandpa Turns 78Old MeInternational Institute for Asian Studies — Forgotten Women Warriors of the MCPPuri - Rath Yatra in the Asian GeographicRoses - Rafa's wife, also the only waitress

Recent Comments

  • niki: I’m sure this wasn’t just a stunt, or is it? Haha. That guy...
  • Chiang: awesome!
  • Erica: Soo funny :D I’ve never seen anything like it before.
  • abi: Thats pure rude! Next time when you get such calls…You should get...
  • Tania: Yes this is belated but great seeing you at ContraDiction and it was a...


©2008 Popagandhi
Powered by WordPress using the Gridline Lite theme by Graph Paper Press.