Popagandhi

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Contact
  • Departments
    • dispatch
    • food and music
    • general
    • glbt
    • site
    • soundbites
    • tech
    • travel
  • Subscribe via RSS

Like A Straw Up Your Nose

October 24th, 2007  |  Published in glbt  |  17 Comments

Best sound bite from the 377A debate: of course it had to be from the Nominated MP and noted legal expert, Thio Li-Ann. Unless you’ve been living under a rock all this time, her anti-gay views are famous (and famously loud). I’m not outraged because I already knew what to expect.

Anal-penetrative sex is inherently damaging to the body and a misuse of organs, like shoving a straw up your nose to drink. The anus is designed to expel waste; when something is forcibly inserted into it, the muscles contract and cause tearing; fecal waste, viruses carried by sperm and blood thus congregate, with adverse health implications like ‘gay bowel syndrome’, anal cancer. ‘Acts of gross indecency’ under 377A also covers unhygienic practices like “rimming†where the mouth comes into contact with the anus. Consent to harmful acts is no defence – otherwise, our strong anti-drug laws must fall as it cannot co-exist with letting in recreational drugs as a matter of personal lifestyle choice [..] Opposite-sex sodomy is harmful, but medical studies indicate that same-sex sodomy carries a higher price tag for society because of higher promiscuity and frequency levels.

Update
In my haste to post, I forgot the following gem:

Second, while homosexuals are a numerical minority, there is no such thing as ‘sexual minorities’ at law. Activists have coined this term to draw a beguiling but fallacious association between homosexuals and legally recognized minorities like racial groups. Race is a fixed trait. It remains controversial whether homosexual orientation is genetic or environmental, perhaps both. There are no ex-Blacks but there are ex-gays. The analogy between race and sexual orientation or preferred sexual preferences, is false. Activists repeat the slogan ‘sexual minority’ ad nausem as a deceptive political ploy to get sympathy from people who don’t think through issues carefully [...] While we cherish racial and religious diversity, sexual diversity is a different kettle of fish. Diversity is not license for perversity. This radical liberal argument is pernicious, a leftist philosophy based on radical individualism and radical egalitarianism. It is unworkable because every viable moral theory has limits to consent.

Actually, there aren’t really any ex-gays either. It depends on who you ask. If the only people you ask are from Focus on the Family, NARTH, Exodus, or other such abominable organizations, one’s perspective of the ex-gay lie might be overwhelmingly optimistic. The ex-gay ministry is precisely that — a ministry. What role does this Christian baggage have in a secular nation such as ours? It’s so easy to label anybody who disagrees with you as liberal, leftist, and radical egalitarian — the truth is, it’s not a gay thing. It doesn’t take a gay person to feel disappointed by what this country witnessed yesterday. There are heterosexual, Christian, right-leaning people who are disappointed too — people who are disappointed that the name of our great religion has often been used to justify all the wrongs of the world.

Watch clips from the debate; read about it. I rest my case; I don’t want to care anymore.

Elsewhere
Hiding Behind Rhetoric Pleinelune’s point by point rebuttal
On 377A Nonsense in the Reasonable Hall of the Sensible Nation Some interesting thoughts
Ex-Gay Harm from an ex-gay survivor, since we’re on that topic
The Molly Awards
Parliamentary Classic: 377A (Part 1)
If Ned Were in Parliament

  • k
    I was about to say something. But then i saw "No comments" splashed on the screen, as no one has said anything with regards to this entry yet. That two words really cleared my mind.

    I now have no comments on the issue either.
  • oli
    It would be pretty funny if they started charging people with 'misuse of organs.' If I breathe in and out to the tune of Jingle Bells is that a misuse of my lungs? Perhaps Thio Li-Ann could supply us with a list of acceptable uses for all the organs of the body.

    And surely kissing is a misuse of the mouth. If you hug someone thats a misuse of the hands. Hands are for drowning kittens.
  • DK
    But then, they own their organs. They like to misuse it, its THEIR problem. Why bother?
  • Julianne
    I guess Singaporeans are literally owned by the Govt. We cant die peacefully without being embarassed and handcuff when we commit suicide. We have to make sure we live up to 80 in order to receive our pay outs for CPF. Now we cant even control what we do in private. Life rocks!
  • donaq
    By that token, shouldn't fasting be criminalised too? After all, starving isn't good for the body and religion isn't a *fixed* trait.
  • philosophyjun
    she needs a good fark.
    up her ass.

    oops, did i say that?
    *blush*
  • Bill Claxton
    I'm hetero. I signed the petition and it got trivialised. The position of silent gays was mentioned in Parlaiment, but not the vocal heteros who object to Section 377A.

    My position is that protections and prohibitions must be applied equally. It is ridiculous to proscribe certain behaviours then allow them for one group and disallow them for another group. If Ms. Thio was really a 'legal expert' she'd admit the hypocrisy of this.

    I'm as disappointed as you Adrianna.
  • Pat Law
    I paid her a tribute for inspiring my latest series of wallpapers here. Let me know what you think.

    http://patlaw.wordpress.com/2007/10/28/straws-a...
  • Satya
    Bizarre!! This lady is an expert?? And she teaches and writes on human rights and laws?? She is a barrister, and has a doctorate and masters degrees in laws from top notch law schools in the US and England? She's a great speaker - a demagogue!! She's truly a Goebbels (perhaps even a Hitler?) in the making - I shudder to think of her in a position of leadership, and I worry about the hundreds of students she is 'mis-educating'!

    I am scared...
  • Harrison
    satya, I wouldn't be so generous as to accord her the electrifying presence of Goebbels, let alone Hitler. Her speech failed to strike any ground with a substantial proportion of people, as can be seen by the vociferous response to her tirade against homosexuality. She sounds more like a ideological mouthpiece for the Christian fundamentalist network in the US - which makes her more of a puppet than anything else.

    pat law, brilliant work on the wallpapers!
  • magnus
    Did you listen to PM Lee's response? He makes a seriously good point, makes me proud that he's our PM.
  • popagandhi
    Yes, I was pretty amazed.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Photostream

Dubai - AliaBaby mikiAh Gong and IAh Gong and IAh Gong and ILondon - Z does her best monkey face

Recent Comments

  • Samantha: My condolences. My paternal grandfather died even before I was born...
  • Tan Geng Hui: Please accept my most sincere condolences, be brave and...
  • Hakoto: Thank you for sharing. My condolences
  • Jun: Hugs babe. It's never easy to lose someone you know your whole life....
  • Aen Tan: Never knew my grandfathers, they were all dead before I was adopted....


©2009 Popagandhi
Powered by WordPress using the Gridline Lite theme by Graph Paper Press.